EditThisPic vs Luminar Neo: Browser AI vs Desktop AI Editor
Desktop AI editor with sliders and tools vs browser AI editor with plain English prompts. Two different approaches to AI editing.
The Verdict
Luminar Neo is a powerful desktop AI photo editor ($149 one-time or $119/year) with sky replacement, portrait retouching, and layer support. EditThisPic takes a simpler approach: describe any edit in plain English and AI does the work, free in your browser. No download, no account needed. Luminar gives more control; EditThisPic is faster and more accessible.
| Feature | EditThisPic | Luminar |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free tier + pay-as-you-go | $149 one-time or $119/year |
| Installation | None - works in browser | Desktop download required (2+ GB) |
| Learning Curve | None - describe what you want | Low-moderate - AI tools with sliders |
| Sky Replacement | Describe the sky you want | Dedicated AI Sky tool with sky library |
| Portrait Retouching | Describe what to fix | Dedicated Face AI, Skin AI, Body AI tools |
| Object Removal | Describe what to remove | Erase tool with manual brushing |
| RAW Processing | JPEG/PNG/WebP only | Full RAW support with develop tools |
| Speed for Quick Edits | 15-30 seconds in browser | 2-5 minutes (launch, import, adjust, export) |
| Layers & Masking | Not available | Layer support with masking tools |
| Mobile Access | Full functionality | Desktop only, no mobile app |
Frequently Asked Questions
Luminar Neo's Sky AI is purpose-built for sky replacement with a curated library and automatic relighting. EditThisPic can replace skies via text description, which is faster but offers less precise control over the exact result.
Yes. EditThisPic works fully on any mobile browser - iPhone, Android, tablet. Luminar Neo is desktop-only with no mobile version. If you need to edit photos on the go, EditThisPic is the clear choice.
Both use modern AI models. For generative tasks like object removal and background replacement, quality is comparable. Luminar Neo's specialized AI tools (Sky AI, Face AI, Skin AI) offer more fine-tuned results for their specific use cases because they're purpose-built.
If you primarily use Luminar for quick AI fixes, EditThisPic handles those for free. If you rely on RAW processing, batch editing, portrait-specific tools, or the sky library, keep Luminar Neo. Many photographers use both - Luminar for serious work, EditThisPic for quick fixes.
Try EditThisPic Free
No signup required. Start editing in seconds.
Try It Free